The Dark Side of Glassdoor Ratings: Dealing with False & Misleading Reviews
Like any review/social media platform, Glassdoor is vulnerable to false or misleading reviews, which can damage a company’s reputation and affect job seekers’ perceptions. In this blog post, I explore the dark side of Glassdoor ratings and list proven ways for dealing with false reviews.
Table of Contents
Impact of False Glassdoor Reviews
False reviews on Glassdoor can have a significant impact on a company’s reputation, potentially leading to a loss of trust from job seekers, current employees, and even investors. It is essential for companies to understand the impact of these reviews and to develop strategies for dealing with them.
First and foremost, false Glassdoor reviews can damage a company’s reputation by providing inaccurate or misleading information about the company’s culture, work environment, and policies. This misinformation can deter potential candidates from applying for open positions and even lead to the loss of current employees who may believe the false information presented in the review.
Additionally, false Glassdoor reviews can negatively impact a company’s overall rating on the platform, which is often one of the first things job seekers look at when researching potential employers. A low rating can make it difficult for a company to attract top talent and can also lead to negative publicity in the media.
Do you know how talent perceivees your brand? Audit it now.
The Anatomy of Misleading Glassdoor Reviews
Misleading Glassdoor reviews can take different forms, but they all share one thing in common: they provide inaccurate or misleading information that can damage a company’s reputation. Here are some common examples of misleading Glassdoor reviews:
- Former employees who were terminated or let go leaving negative reviews: Some former employees may leave negative reviews out of bitterness or revenge after being fired. These reviews can contain exaggerated or false claims about the company’s culture, management, and work environment. For example, a disgruntled employee may leave a review claiming that the company discriminates against certain groups, even though there is no evidence to support this claim.
- Competitors or fake accounts leaving fake reviews: Competitors or fake accounts can leave false reviews to damage a company’s reputation. These reviews can be difficult to spot, as they may contain accurate information mixed with false claims. For example, a competitor may leave a review claiming that the company has a toxic work culture, even though the company has received awards for its positive workplace environment.
- Reviewers leaving reviews that are not reflective of the company’s current state: Some reviews may be outdated or not reflective of the company’s current state. For example, a review from several years ago may criticize the company for poor management, even though the company has since implemented changes to improve management practices.
Detecting False Reviews on Glassdoor
Detecting false reviews on Glassdoor can be challenging, but there are some tell-tale signs to look out for. Here are some common ways to detect false reviews:
- Unusual timing: False reviews may be posted during unusual times, such as weekends or late at night, which may indicate that they were posted by a fake account.
- Extreme language: False reviews may contain extreme language, such as “worst company ever” or “best company in the world,” which may indicate that they are not a genuine reflection of the reviewer’s experience.
- Generic or vague language: False reviews may contain generic or vague language, such as “the management was terrible” or “the work environment was toxic,” without providing specific examples or details.
- Multiple reviews from the same IP address: False reviews may be posted from the same IP address, which may indicate that they were posted by a competitor or fake account.
For example, if a company suddenly receives a large number of negative reviews within a short period of time, it may be a sign that someone is trying to damage the company’s reputation. Additionally, if a review contains extreme language or lacks specific details, it may be a sign that the reviewer is not being truthful.
To detect false reviews, you can use review monitoring services that use artificial intelligence to identify patterns and trends in reviews. These services can help in identifying suspicious activity and take action to address false reviews.
Taking Action Against False Reviews
Here are some common steps that companies can take to address false reviews:
Respond to the review: Companies can respond to the false review to provide their perspective and correct any inaccurate information. This can help to show potential job seekers that the company is proactive and transparent.
Flag the review: Companies can flag the false review on Glassdoor and provide evidence to support their claim that the review is false. Glassdoor will investigate the claim and remove the review if it violates their community guidelines.
Conduct an internal investigation: Companies can investigate the source of the false review by reviewing their employment records, email logs, and other relevant information. This can help to identify the reviewer and take appropriate action.
For example, if a company identifies a false review that was posted by a former employee who was terminated for misconduct, they can provide evidence to Glassdoor and have the review removed. Additionally, if a company identifies a fake review that was posted by a competitor, they can take legal action to protect their reputation and seek damages.
Protecting Your Company’s Reputation
Here are some strategies you can use to safeguard your company’s image:
- Monitor your online presence regularly. Keep a close eye on your Glassdoor profile and set up alerts to notify you of any new reviews or comments. This way, you can quickly respond to any negative feedback and address any concerns.
- Respond to reviews professionally. When responding to false Glassdoor reviews, it’s important to remain calm and professional. Don’t get defensive or angry, as this can reflect poorly on your company. Instead, thank the reviewer for their feedback and offer to address their concerns privately.
- Flag any false or misleading reviews. If you suspect that a Glassdoor review is fake or misleading, you can flag it for removal. Glassdoor has strict guidelines for reviews, and they will investigate any reviews that are flagged.
- Encourage positive reviews from your employees. The best way to combat false Glassdoor reviews is to have a strong base of positive reviews. Encourage your employees to leave honest reviews about their experience working for your company.
Here’s an example of how these strategies can be put into action:
Let’s say a disgruntled former employee leaves a scathing review on Glassdoor, claiming that your company has a toxic work environment and terrible management. You immediately respond to the review, thanking the reviewer for their feedback and expressing your regret that they didn’t have a positive experience working for your company. You also offer to discuss their concerns further in a private setting.
You then investigate the review and find that the former employee left your company on bad terms and may have had an agenda in leaving the negative review. You flag the review for removal, and Glassdoor investigates and removes the review.
Finally, you encourage your current employees to leave honest reviews on Glassdoor, highlighting the positive aspects of working for your company. As a result, your company’s Glassdoor profile becomes more balanced, and potential candidates are more likely to see an accurate picture of what it’s like to work for your company.
FAQs / TL;DR
Find answers to often asked questions below:
What are some common types of false or misleading reviews on Glassdoor?
- Fake reviews: posted by people who never worked for your company, or who did work for your company but are misrepresenting their experience. These reviews may be posted by competitors, ex-employees with a grudge, or even bots.
- Biased reviews: written by individuals who have a particular agenda or bias and may exaggerate or downplay the company.
- Inaccurate reviews:reviews may contain factual errors or misrepresentations about your company.
- Disproportionate reviews: reviews may be outliers, either overly positive or negative, and may not accurately reflect the experiences
How do false or misleading reviews on Glassdoor affect job seekers and employers?
For job seekers:
- False reviews mislead about a company's reputation into believing that a company is worse (or better) than it actually is.
- Negative reviews can damage a company's reputation and attract fewer quality candidates.
- Conflicting information on Glassdoor can cause confusion about what offers to accept/reject.
For employers:
- False reviews provide an unfair representation of a company.
- Reduced trust can lead to decreased loyalty and commitment.
- Negative impact on employee morale may result in decreased productivity and higher turnover.
Can Glassdoor detect and remove false or misleading reviews?
Yes, Glassdoor has a team of moderators who use advanced algorithms and manual reviews to detect and remove false and misleading reviews that violate their community guidelines. However, it's important to flag these reviews for removal and provide evidence to support your claim.
Glassdoor has an active community to help monitor users. They encourage users to flag fraudulent reviews.
What steps can employers take to respond to false or misleading reviews on Glassdoor?
Employers can flag the false or misleading review for violation of Glassdoor's community guidelines and provide evidence to support their claim. They can also respond publicly to the review and offer their side of the story.
Additionally, employers can encourage current and former employees to leave honest reviews to counterbalance the false ones. They can also work to improve their company's culture and address any legitimate concerns raised in the false reviews.
Are there any legal implications for posting false or misleading reviews on Glassdoor?
Posting false reviews can result in legal consequences, such as defamation lawsuits or violating consumer protection laws. Employers may also take legal action against individuals who post fake reviews to protect their brand reputation. It's important for users to be truthful and accurate in their reviews to avoid any legal repercussions.
How important are Glassdoor ratings and reviews in the job search process?
There's no doubt that they provide valuable insights into a company's culture, work-life balance, salary, benefits, management style, and career growth opportunities for job seekers. However, it's important to use them alongside other resources and take them with a grain of salt, as reviews can be subjective and may not reflect every employee's experiences.
Can employers incentivize employees to post positive reviews on Glassdoor?
Negative, is prohibited and goes against Glassdoor's community guidelines. Any attempt to manipulate reviews in this way can result in removal of the reviews and potentially damage the company's reputation on the platform.
Glassdoor says, "have unique technology filters and algorithms to detect this type of fraud. If we learn that an employer has breached this rule, we will remove the reviews immediately."
How do Glassdoor's policies on reviews and ratings compare to other job search websites?
In addition to Glassdoor, other job search sites such as Blind and AmbitionBox also offer company ratings and reviews. Blind is particularly known for its anonymous forums where employees can share insights and opinions on their workplaces, while AmbitionBox is popular in India for its ratings and reviews on employers. However, it's important to note that the quality and reliability of ratings can differ across platforms, so it's advisable to use multiple sources to get a well-rounded view of a company's reputation.
You May Also Like to Read: